Central bankers and policymakers are wrestling with how to account for risks associated with the transition to a net-zero economy as they seek to address climate change and incorporate those risks in their future monetary policy planning.
So-called physical risks from climate change – economic costs associated with more extreme weather events – are relatively measurable, but transition risks are a more complicated calculus, according to Kristalina Georgieva, managing director of the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
"It would play over time and it would demonstrate itself as we move towards lower carbon intensity forcefully ," Georgieva said at the Green Swan 2021 conference. "We need to look into this risk already today.
Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team.
"The dirty assets: how are they going to evolve. Their value will decline, would be replaced by others. How do we integrate this is a question we are wrestling with."
Policymakers, advisers and business leaders gathered virtually last week at the Green Swan conference to discuss how to address the climate crisis and incorporate climate targets into financial policy. The conference was co-sponsored by the Bank of International Settlements, the Banque de France, the IMF and the Network for Greening the Financial System.
Co-signers to the 2015 Paris Agreement have agreed to work together to cap peak emissions on greenhouse gases and to seek to limit global warming to below 2 degrees Celsius when compared with pre-industrial levels.
As a result, countries from China to United States have announced plans to reach net zero emissions in the next three to four decades. For example, Chinese President Xi Jinping pledged last September that China would cap its emissions by 2030 and reach carbon neutrality by 2060.
To better manage the economic risks from market-based carbon reduction policies such as emissions trading, China – the world's largest greenhouse gases emitter – should speed up the establishment of road maps for each of the 24 major industries officials have identified, as soon as possible, said Zhou Xiaochuan, a former governor of the People's Bank of China.
"We didn't have a good enough preparation for that in terms of planning and data [collection] when the climate goals were announced," Zhou, currently president of China Society for Finance and Banking, told the conference on Friday. "There are great risks to be expected from carbon markets, we may make some mistakes that we will later need to correct, and which may be costly."
Zhou Xiaochuan, former governor of People's Bank of China, in Beijing in 2018. Photo: Simon Song alt=Zhou Xiaochuan, former governor of People's Bank of China, in Beijing in 2018. Photo: Simon Song
China is due to start spot market trading of carbon emissions in a newly set up national exchange in Shanghai to finance carbon emission projects as soon as this month. Seven operating pilot regional exchanges will eventually be integrated into the national exchange.
Zhou urged other large developing economies to also set up carbon emissions markets to show their determination to implement their climate commitments. At some point, connections among international carbon markets should be considered to provide channels to facilitate financial support and technology transfer from developed to developing nations, he said.
This could be achieved by implementing mechanisms similar to the cross-border Stock Connect schemes that allowed controlled fund flows into and out of stock markets between China and other jurisdictions, he added.
One prominent issue for global leaders is how to deal with older, heavy carbon-emitting industries that may find their assets "stranded" as a result of the shift to net-zero economy.
A disorderly transition to a low-carbon economy could lead to increased credit risk in some industries, namely by reducing the ability of some businesses to service and repay their debts, according to the Financial Stability Board.
Kristalina Georgieva, International Monetary Fund managing director. Photo: AFP alt=Kristalina Georgieva, International Monetary Fund managing director. Photo: AFP
"Credit risk could also result from reductions in the value of collateral against which transactions are secured, particularly when such collateral takes the form of immovable or capital intensive infrastructure that might be particularly affected by climate-related risks," the FSB said in a November 2020 report.
The financial effects of the shift to a low-carbon economy remain hard to pinpoint.
One study estimated the loss in global wealth from stranded assets may range from US$1 trillion to US$4 trillion, according to the FSB. However, reductions in the value of equities and bonds held in financial sector portfolios could reach US$2 trillion alone, which would be less material for financial stability if they occur gradually, according to the FSB.
US President Joe Biden rejoined the Paris climate agreement after taking office in January and said meeting emission targets could create millions of jobs for middle-class Americans as part of the transition.
Mark Carney, the former Bank of England governor, speaks at a meeting of G20 finance ministers and central bank governors in Buenos Aires in 2018. Photo: EPA-EFE alt=Mark Carney, the former Bank of England governor, speaks at a meeting of G20 finance ministers and central bank governors in Buenos Aires in 2018. Photo: EPA-EFE
Climate activists are putting pressure on companies and their lenders to rethink their use of and support of the fossil fuel industry, with activists winning key support from shareholders at ExxonMobil and Chevron in May.
Top bankers, such as HSBC CEO Noel Quinn and Standard Chartered CEO Bill Winters, have resisted pressure to outright dump clients in industries labelled as "dirty", saying they want to support clients in the transition and see it as a business opportunity. However, they said they will walk away from clients that do not demonstrate a willingness to change.
"We're taking it as our mission to help our clients understand their sustainability and their climate position, their position on greenhouse gases to help them transition themselves," Winters said at the company's annual meeting on May 12. "Where we have clients who are unwilling or simply unable to make the transition, they won't be able to bank with Standard Chartered."
Reaching those climate goals, in part, will require mandatory disclosure by the private sector of climate risks to their businesses under standards set by the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), according to Mark Carney, the former Bank of England governor and UN Special Envoy on Climate Action and Finance.
Standard Chartered CEO Bill Winters. Photo: Xiaomei Chen alt=Standard Chartered CEO Bill Winters. Photo: Xiaomei Chen
More than 1,500 private sector firms with a market capitalisation of more than US$17 trillion are reporting their climate risks in line with the TCFD recommendations and many central banks also have followed suit, Carney said.
"We know that climate risks are different from traditional financial risk. They're economy wide. They affect every consumer, every business, every sector. They're global," Carney said. "They're longer term going beyond the usual three to five-year planning horizon for most businesses."
All major jurisdictions should adopt "pathways to comprehensive, compared climate disclosure" based on those recommendations by the 2021 United Nations Climate Change Conference, known as COP26, in November, he said.
Yi Gang, the People's Bank of China Governor, said the central bank would publish climate-related stress testing of the country's financial sector in the future, without giving a specific date.
Gang also said China was "positive" on the TCFD, asking the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, to join as a member.
"Our goal is to make a uniform disclosure standard, and in the future, we will go in the direction of a mandatory disclosure of climate-related information." Gang said during a panel at the conference on Friday.
The Bank of England, for example, outlined a proposal in May to "green" its £20 billion (US$28 billion) corporate bond purchase scheme, in which it buys company debt as a monetary stimulus measure. As part of the proposal, the central bank would align its corporate bond portfolio to UK net-zero goals.
"There is no template for a comprehensive framework for greening an asset portfolio held for monetary policy purposes," Andrew Bailey, the Bank of England governor, said at the Green Swan conference. "We know that outreach and engagement is critical in getting this right, and so are currently seeking feedback on our proposed framework."
One challenge is there is no universal framework for climate reporting, even though the TCFD standards go a long way to standardising the process, policymakers said.
"We're not quite yet on sound footing to have uniformity of standards. [There are] 200 frameworks. It is a little too much to handle," Georgieva, the IMF managing director, said. "We have to go towards narrowing down and accepting that mandatory can only be done when we have a commonality of standardised exposure and accepted frameworks."
Additional reporting by Finbarr Birmingham
This article originally appeared in the South China Morning Post (SCMP), the most authoritative voice reporting on China and Asia for more than a century. For more SCMP stories, please explore the SCMP app or visit the SCMP's Facebook and Twitter pages. Copyright © 2021 South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.
Copyright (c) 2021. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.